Cakes by Abby is a bakeries in Chestertown. Phone: (410) 708-4759. Average rating is 5.0 stars from 27 reviews. Website: https://www.cakesbyabby.net/.
Cakes by Abby
Call Now Directions
Review
Cakes by Abby — By Appointment, Chestertown
5.0 27 reviews

Custom Cakes That Steal the Show

By-appointment cake design in Chestertown for weddings, celebrations, and standout desserts made with care.

About Us

Cakes by Abby is the kind of bakery people remember long after the last slice is gone. By appointment in Chestertown, this is where celebration cakes are shaped with patience, precision, and a clear eye for beauty. Every order feels personal, because the work is built around your vision, your event, and the details that make a cake feel like it truly belongs there.

Customers consistently praise Abby for creating cakes that are thoughtful, polished, and deeply personal. That care shows in the way each design is handled, from the first conversation to the finished presentation. The result is a cake that looks elegant on the table and feels meaningful to serve, whether it is for a wedding, a milestone, or another important gathering.

With a 5.0 rating from 27 reviews, Cakes by Abby has built a strong reputation on creativity, responsiveness, and beautiful results. If you want a cake that feels custom from the start, this Chestertown appointment-based bakery brings artistry and attention together in a way that stands out.

What We Offer

At Cakes by Abby, the focus is custom cake work designed to match the tone of your celebration. From elegant wedding cakes to cakes for birthdays, showers, and special events, every order is approached with a made-for-you mindset. The experience is personal, collaborative, and tailored to the look and feel you want on the day that matters.

Abby is known for turning ideas into finished designs that feel refined and intentional. That includes wedding cakes that make a statement, as well as dessert options that can round out a celebration with style. The emphasis is on thoughtful design, reliable execution, and a finished cake that brings the whole event together.

Because service is by appointment in Chestertown, clients get focused attention and a more customized process. That gives room for creative planning, clear communication, and a result that reflects your event instead of a one-size-fits-all template. For celebrations that deserve something personal, this is a bakery built around detail.

Why Choose Us

5.0 rating from 27 reviews, reflecting consistent praise for beautiful, thoughtful cake design.
By-appointment service in Chestertown creates a focused, personalized experience from start to finish.
Known for cakes that feel personal and polished, especially for weddings and major celebrations.
Clients describe Abby as efficient and easy to work with, with results that match the original vision.
A strong reputation for presentation and care makes each order feel tailored rather than routine.

Gallery

Take a look at our space and what we have to offer

What Our Customers Say

Don't just take our word for it - hear from our satisfied customers

Click to Rate & Review This Business ✍️
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
4 months ago
"We absolutely love working with Cakes by Abby! Abby creates some of the most beautiful and thoughtful wedding cakes we’ve had the pleasure of seeing, and every design feels incredibly personal, elegant, and artistic. As florists at Wildly Native Flower Farm, one of our favorite things is seeing the way she incorporates our fresh, locally grown flowers into her cake designs so seamlessly. She truly understands how to let florals enhance a cake without overpowering it, and the end result is always stunning. Beyond the beauty of her work, Abby is kind, professional, creative, and wonderful to collaborate with behind the scenes. We always know her cakes will not only look incredible at weddings and events across the Eastern Shore, but taste amazing too. We’re so grateful to partner with another local creative who values seasonal beauty, artistry, and supporting fellow small businesses. Highly recommend Cakes by Abby for anyone looking for a wedding cake that is both gorgeous and delicious!"
— Wildly Native Team
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
2 months ago
"Abby did an incredible job with our wedding cake! She was wonderful to work with and made our idea come to life perfectly. We also ordered brownies, which were delicious. I highly recommend the almond cake with vanilla frosting- so good! We couldn’t have been happier and would absolutely recommend her!"
— Marisa Wade
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
2 months ago
"Abby’s cakes were wonderful from the tasting all the way to the day of delivery and additional sheet cake. I would recommend Abby and her flavors to anyone. She is very efficient and delivers 10x with her cakes!"
— Ally Scheimreif
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
2 months ago
"This review is long overdue. Abby created the most beautiful cake for my parents’ 40th wedding anniversary. Her work is pure art. We all felt guilty cutting into it. The cake was just as delicious as it was stunning, and everything about it felt magical. Beyond her incredible talent, Abby is an exceptional human being. Her kindness continues to amaze me. When I reached out to her as an anxious new baker, she took time out of her busy schedule to answer each and every question I had. It is almost impossible to find selfless people like her. She deserves every bit of success that comes her way. She is truly a woman of integrity and principle. I promise you, you will never regret hiring het"
— Mahlet Mersha
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
2 months ago
"Abby was great to work with! She is incredibly artistic and talented, and she really brought our vision for our wedding cake to life. We had quite a few indecisive moments throughout the planning process, and she was very patient and flexible with us. She also took the time to answer all of our questions about sizing and guest count, which we really appreciated. We'd definitely recommend her to anyone looking for a beautiful custom wedding cake!"
— Abby Sheehan

Frequently Asked Questions

What type of bakery is Cakes by Abby?

Cakes by Abby is a by-appointment bakery in Chestertown that specializes in custom cake work for celebrations and special events.

Do you make wedding cakes?

Yes. Wedding cakes are a major part of the business, and the designs are known for being personal, elegant, and carefully finished.

Is this a walk-in bakery?

No. The business is listed as by appointment, so planning ahead is the best way to connect and discuss your cake needs.

What kinds of events do you serve?

Cakes by Abby is a strong fit for weddings, birthdays, showers, and other celebrations that call for a custom cake.

What makes Cakes by Abby stand out?

Customers consistently mention the thoughtful designs, personal service, and the care that goes into both the creative process and the final result.

Where is Cakes by Abby located?

Cakes by Abby is located in Chestertown and operates by appointment.

71° Partly cloudy
Mon 74° 67°
Tue 66° 57°
Wed 68° 56°
Thu 64° 54°
Fri 70° 48°
Sat 64° 58°
Sun 62° 57°

Get In Touch

Ready to get started? Contact us today!

Save to Contacts
Presented by Doozer Town

The best of Chestertown

Top of the board by the Doozer Ranking: reviews, ratings, what people wrote, and how many hours a week they are open.

See the whole Chestertown board →

Around the neighborhood

Other places near here, whatever their type.

Everything in Chestertown on one board →

Contact Cakes by Abby

Send a note and Cakes by Abby will get back to you. No account needed.

Add an email or a phone so they can reply.

Best time to reach you

Report an issue

See something off? Tell us. We’ll fix it and improve the listing for everyone. No account required.